Why Some Families Need More Than One Trust | Repair The Roof Podcast

Subscribe where ever you listen to Podcasts:

Resources:

In this episode, estate planning attorney Ted Gudorf discusses the complexities of estate planning and the various types of trusts that families may need. He explains the importance of having multiple trusts to address different risks and protect assets for spouses and children. Ted emphasizes the role of revocable living trusts as a foundation, while also highlighting the need for specialized trusts for retirement accounts and special needs beneficiaries. He concludes by stressing that the effectiveness of an estate plan lies in its clear purpose and proper funding.

One Trust Can Avoid Probate. But Can It Protect Everything Else?

You may walk into an estate planning meeting expecting one simple trust.

Then your attorney starts talking about a marital trust for your spouse, separate inheritance trusts for your children, a retirement trust, a special needs trust, or even an irrevocable trust for long-term care planning.

Suddenly, what seemed like a straightforward estate plan feels much more complicated.

But there is an important reason multiple trusts may come up.

A revocable living trust can be an excellent foundation for an estate plan, but it isn't designed to solve every problem your family could encounter. Avoiding probate is only one objective.

Protecting a surviving spouse, preserving an inheritance from creditors, coordinating retirement accounts, maintaining eligibility for certain government benefits, and addressing long-term care concerns can require very different planning tools.

The question isn't, "How many trusts should I have?"

A better question is:

"What risks does my estate plan actually need to address?"

Understanding that distinction can make a complicated-looking estate plan much easier to evaluate.

Your Revocable Living Trust Is the Foundation

For many families, the revocable living trust is where estate planning begins.

A properly structured living trust can help you:

  • Avoid probate for appropriately titled assets
  • Provide for management of assets during incapacity
  • Establish instructions for distributing property after death
  • Keep certain estate administration matters outside the public probate process

Those are significant benefits.

But a revocable trust also has an important limitation.

Because you generally retain control over the assets while you're alive, simply transferring property into a revocable trust doesn't automatically shield those assets from your creditors, lawsuits, or potential long-term care expenses.

And after your death, distributing everything outright to your beneficiaries may expose their inheritance to risks in their own lives.

That is where additional trusts can become relevant.

Think about insurance for a moment.

You wouldn't expect one insurance policy to simultaneously cover every risk associated with your home, vehicle, health, and long-term care.

Trusts can work similarly.

Different trusts can be designed for different purposes.

Insight #1: More Trusts Don't Necessarily Mean a More Complicated Estate

Seeing several trusts in an estate plan can initially look like unnecessary complexity.

Sometimes, however, the opposite is true.

A well-designed plan may use different trusts because the family has several distinct objectives.

One trust may manage your property.

Another may provide for your surviving spouse.

Another may protect a child's inheritance.

Another may address a beneficiary with special needs.

The important question isn't the number of documents or trusts involved. It's whether each component has a clear job.

In fact, some trusts included in an estate plan don't necessarily operate as separate trusts during your lifetime. They may be created later under the provisions of your primary estate planning documents.

That distinction is important.

Multiple trusts don't automatically mean multiple piles of paperwork that you have to manage every day.

What matters is understanding when each trust becomes effective, what assets it controls, who manages it, and what problem it's intended to address.

Protecting a Surviving Spouse

Many married couples use a straightforward approach: when the first spouse dies, everything passes to the surviving spouse.

That may be appropriate in some circumstances.

But consider what could happen afterward.

The surviving spouse could eventually require long-term care. They could remarry. Their estate plan could change. They might experience diminished capacity or become vulnerable to someone else's influence.

Blended families introduce another concern.

Suppose both spouses have children from previous relationships. If everything passes outright to the surviving spouse, that spouse may ultimately have the ability to redirect those assets.

The deceased spouse's children could potentially receive less than originally intended—or nothing at all.

A properly designed marital trust can address some of these concerns.

Instead of transferring unrestricted ownership of everything to the surviving spouse, the trust can provide access to assets according to its terms while establishing instructions for where the remaining property eventually goes.

This can be especially relevant for:

  • Second marriages
  • Blended families
  • Couples with children from previous relationships
  • Families concerned about preserving assets for future beneficiaries

The objective isn't necessarily to restrict the surviving spouse.

It's to balance the surviving spouse's needs with the family's longer-term estate planning goals.

Protecting Your Children's Inheritance

Once you've addressed your spouse, another question appears:

What happens when your children receive their inheritance?

Many estate plans simply divide the remaining assets equally among the children.

That's easy to understand.

But once an inheritance is distributed outright, the protections available through the trust may disappear.

Imagine that a beneficiary receives a significant inheritance while facing a lawsuit.

Or perhaps they're going through a divorce.

Maybe they work in a profession with elevated liability exposure or have ongoing creditor problems.

An inheritance that arrives at exactly the wrong time can become exposed to circumstances you never intended to benefit.

Instead of automatically distributing an inheritance outright, an estate plan may establish a separate inheritance trust for each child.

When properly structured and administered, these trusts may offer protection depending on applicable law and the trust's terms while still allowing the beneficiary to benefit from the assets.

This leads to another important principle.

Insight #2: Equal Doesn't Always Mean Identical

Parents frequently want to treat their children equally.

But equal inheritances don't necessarily require identical planning.

Consider three children receiving equal shares.

One might be financially experienced but work in a profession with meaningful liability exposure.

Another might be navigating a difficult marriage.

A third could have challenges managing significant amounts of money.

The dollar amount inherited could be identical while the structure surrounding each inheritance is different.

That flexibility allows an estate plan to respond to the beneficiary's circumstances rather than assuming every beneficiary faces the same risks.

And for certain beneficiaries, the stakes can be even higher.

When a Beneficiary Has Special Needs

Leaving assets directly to a beneficiary who receives means-tested government benefits can create unintended consequences.

Programs such as Medicaid and Supplemental Security Income (SSI) have eligibility requirements.

Depending on the circumstances, receiving an inheritance outright can affect eligibility.

A properly designed special needs trust can potentially allow assets to be used for the beneficiary according to the trust's terms without placing those assets directly into the beneficiary's ownership.

The trust may help provide for expenses such as housing, transportation, education, or personal needs while coordinating with applicable benefit rules.

This trust has a fundamentally different purpose from your revocable living trust.

Your living trust primarily manages and distributes your estate.

A special needs trust focuses on the circumstances of a particular beneficiary.

Trying to make one generic trust accomplish both jobs without appropriate provisions can create problems.

Retirement Accounts Require Special Attention

Here is an area that families frequently overlook:

Your retirement accounts may require different planning from the rest of your estate.

IRAs, 401(k)s, and similar accounts generally pass according to beneficiary designations rather than simply following the instructions governing assets titled in your revocable living trust.

That means beneficiary designations deserve careful attention.

Naming a trust as the beneficiary of a retirement account can also create complex income tax and distribution consequences, so your standard revocable trust isn't automatically the appropriate beneficiary.

In certain situations, a separately designed retirement trust may be considered—for example, when the intended beneficiary is a minor or when controlled access or additional protection is an important objective.

The exact structure matters.

Retirement account rules can affect both the timing and taxation of distributions, and federal law in this area has changed significantly in recent years.

This is one area where seemingly small wording or beneficiary-designation decisions can have substantial consequences.

Review your retirement account beneficiary designations periodically and coordinate them with your overall estate plan.

Knowing who is named is only the beginning.

You should also understand why they're named and whether that designation still accomplishes your objectives.

Insight #3: Your Living Trust Doesn't Automatically Protect Assets From Nursing Home Costs

This misconception can be particularly costly.

Some people assume that transferring assets into a revocable living trust protects those assets when applying for Medicaid long-term care benefits.

Generally, that isn't how a standard revocable trust works.

Because you retain control over assets in a revocable trust, transferring them into the trust doesn't, by itself, make them unavailable for Medicaid eligibility purposes.

Certain irrevocable trusts may be considered as part of advance Medicaid planning.

When appropriately designed for the applicable circumstances and state law, these arrangements may change ownership and control of particular assets while establishing rules for how those assets are handled.

But there is a significant tradeoff.

Irrevocable planning can require giving up rights and control that you would otherwise retain.

Medicaid also has transfer and look-back rules that must be considered.

That's why long-term care planning generally shouldn't begin in the middle of a crisis.

The earlier these issues are evaluated, the more planning options a family may have.

Business and Rental Property May Need Another Layer

Families who own businesses, farms, or rental properties face another set of considerations.

Your revocable living trust might own an interest in a business entity, but that doesn't necessarily mean every business or rental asset should simply be titled directly in the trust.

For example, rental property may be owned through a limited liability company (LLC), with the ownership interest coordinated with the estate plan.

A family business may also require specific provisions governing:

  • Succession
  • Voting rights
  • Management
  • Ownership transfers
  • What happens when an owner dies or becomes incapacitated

In these situations, your trust and business structures should work together.

The trust doesn't replace appropriate business planning.

So, How Many Trusts Do You Actually Need?

Possibly one.

Possibly more.

A single revocable living trust may be sufficient when your family circumstances are relatively straightforward, your intended beneficiaries can appropriately receive their inheritance outright, and you don't have specialized planning concerns.

Additional trusts become worth discussing when you need to address risks such as:

  • Protecting a surviving spouse
  • Providing for children from a previous relationship
  • Protecting a beneficiary's inheritance
  • Planning for a beneficiary with special needs
  • Coordinating substantial retirement accounts
  • Addressing potential long-term care concerns
  • Integrating businesses or rental properties into the estate plan

The objective should never be to accumulate as many trusts as possible.

Every trust should have a specific purpose.

If you leave an estate planning meeting with several trusts in your plan, you should understand what each one does.

Ask:

What problem does this trust solve?

When does it become effective?

Which assets belong in it?

Who controls or manages it?

Who benefits from it?

And what happens if circumstances change?

If those answers aren't clear, keep asking questions.

The Part Even a Great Trust Can't Fix

There is one final issue that can undermine even a carefully designed estate plan.

Funding.

A trust only controls assets that are properly connected to it through appropriate ownership, beneficiary designations, or other planning arrangements.

Creating sophisticated trust documents while failing to properly coordinate the assets can leave the plan unable to accomplish its intended purpose.

That's why signing your estate planning documents shouldn't necessarily be viewed as the end of the process.

Your asset ownership, beneficiary designations, business interests, real estate, and other property should be reviewed to determine whether they're properly coordinated with the plan.

Review What Your Trust Is Actually Designed to Do

Your estate plan doesn't become better simply because it contains more trusts.

And it doesn't become simpler simply because it contains only one.

The right structure depends on your assets, your beneficiaries, your family circumstances, and the risks you're trying to address.

A revocable living trust can provide a powerful foundation, particularly for probate avoidance, incapacity planning, privacy, and distribution of assets.

But it may not, by itself, address every concern involving a surviving spouse, children's inheritances, retirement accounts, beneficiaries with special needs, business interests, or long-term care planning.

Your next step: Review your current estate plan with a qualified estate planning attorney and ask one simple question: "What specific purpose does each trust in my plan serve?"

If you can't clearly answer that question—or you're relying on one trust to accomplish several very different objectives—it may be time for a closer review.

Conclusion

The number of trusts in an estate plan isn't the measure of whether the plan is effective.

Purpose is.

For some families, one properly funded revocable living trust may accomplish what they need. For others, several carefully coordinated trusts can address risks that a single trust was never designed to handle.

Ultimately, the goal is straightforward: every part of your estate plan should have a clear purpose and work as intended when your family eventually needs it.

Transcript: Prefer to Read — Click to Open


Ted (00:00.14)

You may have expected your estate plan to include one simple trust. Instead, your estate planning attorney starts discussing a marital trust, separate trust for each one of your children, perhaps a retirement trust, and an asset protection trust. Now you are wondering whether all of this is truly necessary. One trust may help you avoid probing, but it usually cannot protect your spouse or

Your children’s inheritance, your retirement accounts, and your other assets from every risk. After more than thirty five years of practicing estate planning in the Dayton, Ohio area, I’ve helped hundreds of families determine which trusts they need and which ones they do not. In this episode, I will explain why some families need more than one trust. What each trust does

and how to decide what is right for your family. Let’s start with the trust most people already know about. The Revocable Living Trust is usually the foundation of your plan. Here’s why it matters. This trust can help you avoid probate. Manage your assets if you become mentally incapacitated, and give clear instructions for what happens to your property after you pass away. It also keeps your estate administration private

Instead of running it through a public court process. That’s what a revocable living trust is designed to do. It manages your assets during your lifetime and distributes them the way you’ve instructed. But here’s what most people don’t realize. Because you still control the assets in this trust, it generally does not protect those assets from your own creditors, from any kind of lawsuit against you.

From nursing home costs or a beneficiary’s divorce or a beneficiary’s creditors. The revocable trust is your starting point. For a lot of families, it’s not the entire plan. So if one trust has limits, why would you need more than one? Think about it this way you won’t expect one insurance policy to cover your home, your car, your health, and long term care all at once.

Ted (02:25.758)

Each policy is built for a different risk. Trusts work the same way. One trust might manage your assets while you’re alive. Another might protect your spouse after you’re gone. Another might protect the inheritance that eventually reaches your children. Using more than one trust doesn’t mean your plan is excessive. It usually means your family has more than one problem to solve.

With that in mind, let’s go through those trusts one at a time, starting with the one that protects the person closest to you. The first one most married couples run into is protecting a surviving spouse. A lot of couples leave everything directly to whichever spouse survives. That can work fine, but think about what can happen after the first spouse dies.

Perhaps they end up in a nursing home. Perhaps the surviving spouse remarries. They could change their beneficiaries, they could become incapacitated or someone could take advantage of them. If there are children from a prior marriage, they could end up with nothing. Marital trust for your surviving spouse gives access to income, housing, and support.

Without necessarily handing over unrestricted ownership of everything. The remaining assets still follow the instructions you set up, even after you’re gone. This matters particularly for blended families, second marriages, and couples with children from a prior relationship. Once your spouse is protected, the next question is what happens when the money reaches your children?

A basic plan often says something like divide everything equally amongst the kids. Simple enough, but once that money is distributed outright, you no longer have any say in how it’s protected. I had a client who left her estate equally to her three children. One of them was in the middle of a lawsuit when she passed away. His inheritance went straight into the settlement. If that money had been held in a separate trust for him,

Ted (04:48.842)

Instead of distributing it outright, it would have stayed totally protected, and it would have been one hundred percent his. A separate inheritance trust for each child can protect that inheritance from their divorces, lawsuits, creditors, bankruptcy, or their spouse who may later inherit it if something happens to your child. Your child can still use the money, invest it, and benefit from it.

The trust doesn’t restrict them. It protects the asset from what happens around them. Your children don’t need identical plants just because they’re getting an equal inheritance. One child might be financially responsible but work in a high liability profession. Another might be going through a divorce. Another might struggle with debt or money management. Equal doesn’t have to mean identical.

That flexibility matters even more when one of your beneficiaries depends on government support to get by. If you have a child or grandchild with special needs, you’re dealing with a completely different problem. If that beneficiary receives government benefits like Medicaid or SSI, an inheritance left directly to them can disqualify them from those benefits. However, a special needs trust allows money to be used for their housing.

transportation, education, or personal care without placing the inheritance directly in their name. This trust does a completely different job than the trust managing your own estate. One distributes your assets, the other protects a beneficiary’s eligibility for the support they depend on. So far we’ve covered how to protect people. Now let’s cover an asset type that often gets overlooked constantly your retirement accounts.

Here’s a piece a lot of people miss entirely, and it surprises even experienced estate planners. Your retirement accounts don’t always belong in the same trust as everything else. IRAs, 401ks, and other retirement accounts pass through beneficiary designations, not typically through your revocable living trust. And your standard revocable living trust isn’t always the right beneficiary for those accounts.

Ted (07:18.838)

If a beneficiary is a minor, financially irresponsible, going through a divorce, or shouldn’t have unrestricted access to the funds, a separately designed retirement trust may be the better fit. The language in that trust has to be written very carefully because it directly affects how and when those distributions get taxed. Take a few minutes this week and pull up the beneficiary designations on your retirement accounts.

Check who’s listed. If it’s a person instead of a trust, or if you’re not sure why it’s set up that way, that’s worth a conversation with your estate planning attorney. Retirement accounts aren’t the only thing people assume is already covered. The same is true for long term care. Let’s clear up one more misconception because I hear this all the time. People believe putting assets into a revocable living trust is

protects them from nursing home costs. It does not. Because you still control the assets in a revocable trust, they are still counted as available when you apply for Medicaid long term care benefits. An irrevocable trust, on the other hand, properly designed, can sometimes be used for advanced Medicaid planning. It can remove certain assets from your direct ownership, preserve them for your spouse or children, and

And create clearer rules around access and control. But this type of trust requires you to give up certain rights and it has to account for the Medicaid look back period. This is why Medicaid planning needs to happen well before a health crisis, not during one. There’s one more category of assets that follows its own set of rules, and it applies if you own a business, rental property, or a farm.

Your living trust might own an interest in a business or an LLC, but placing every asset directly into that same trust without thinking about liability isn’t always the right move. Rental property is often better held in an LLC, with that ownership interest then connected to your estate plan. A family business may need its own rules for succession, voting, and ownership transfers. The trust works alongside these structures.

Ted (09:46.378)

It doesn’t replace them. At this point you might be thinking this sounds like a lot of paperwork. Here’s the reassurance. A well designed plan organizes each trust around a clear purpose. The living trust manages your assets. The marital trust protects your spouse. Each child’s trust protects that child’s inheritance. The retirement trusts receive specific retirement assets.

The Medicaid Trust addresses long term care. Some of these trusts may not even exist as separate accounts during your lifetime. They’re often created only after death under the terms of your main trust. You should walk away from your planning meeting knowing exactly what each trust takes effect, what goes into it, who manages it, and what it protects.

If your attorney can’t explain that clearly, that’s worth asking more questions about. And to be clear, not every family needs multiple trusts. One revocable living trust is often enough if your family situation is straightforward, your beneficiaries are responsible adults, there’s no blended family involved, and you don’t have significant creditor divorce or long term care concerns. The goal here is not to create as many trusts as possible, but

The goal is to solve the problems your family is most likely to face. For some families, one living trust is completely appropriate. But for others, that same trust might avoid probate, but do very little to protect a surviving spouse, a child’s inheritance, retirement accounts, a special needs beneficiary, business assets, or the family’s assets from future nursing home costs. The number of trusts you have is

Is not what determines whether your estate plan is good. What matters is whether every part of the plan has a clear purpose and whether it will actually work when your family needs it to work. So now you know why some families need more than one trust, and just as important when one trust is genuinely enough. But knowing which trust you need is only half the equation. If those trusts aren’t properly funded with your actual assets,

Ted (12:08.642)

They won’t protect anything at all. Click on seven key trust assets and how to effectively fund them into your trust to see exactly what needs to be retitled and how to do it correctly.

Back to All Episodes