Florida Community Property Trust For Ohio Resident and The Upcoming Estate Tax Cliff with Craig R. Hersch | Repair The Roof Podcast

Subscribe where ever you listen to Podcasts:

Resources:

Attorney Ted Gudorf and Attorney Craig Hirsch discuss the Florida Community Property Trust and how it can benefit Ohio residents. The trust allows residents of common law states to receive community property tax treatment, which includes a step-up in tax cost basis. The trust applies to most assets, such as real estate, business interests, and investments, but not qualified retirement accounts. Community property states provide a full step-up in basis for both spouses, while common law states only provide a step-up for the deceased spouse's share.

The Florida Community Property Trust allows Ohio residents to achieve community property status and receive the associated tax benefits. The federal estate tax exemption is currently over $13 million but is set to decrease to around $7 million in 2026. Taking advantage of the current exemption by making gifts during one's lifetime can help avoid estate tax. The generation skipping transfer tax exemption is also important for estate planning. Overall, the Florida Community Property Trust and strategic gifting can provide significant tax benefits for individuals with highly appreciated assets.

How a Florida Community Property Trust Could Save Ohio Families Thousands in Capital Gains Taxes

You Don't Have to Live in Florida to Explore a Powerful Estate Planning Strategy That Could Protect More of Your Family's Wealth

Imagine you and your spouse purchased a property for $200,000. Over the years, its value grows to $1 million.

You've built substantial wealth, but there's a hidden tax issue that could affect your surviving spouse when one of you passes away.

If your spouse decides to sell the property, they could face capital gains taxes on hundreds of thousands of dollars in appreciation.

But what if a trust established under Florida law could potentially reduce or eliminate that tax burden, even though you live in Ohio?

That's the opportunity behind a Florida Community Property Trust.

On the Repair the Roof podcast, Attorney Ted Gudorf spoke with Florida estate planning attorney Craig Hersch about how these trusts work, why they matter for married couples, and what Ohio property owners should understand before considering this strategy.

The potential benefits are significant, but so are the legal and tax considerations.

Understanding the Hidden Tax Problem in Jointly Owned Property

Many married couples assume that when one spouse passes away, the surviving spouse automatically receives all jointly owned property without any significant tax consequences.

While the transfer itself may not trigger capital gains taxes, selling that property later can create an unexpected tax bill.

The issue comes down to something called cost basis.

Your cost basis generally represents what you originally paid for an asset, adjusted for certain expenses, improvements, and other tax-related factors.

For example, suppose you purchased a home for $150,000 and later spent $50,000 on qualifying improvements.

Your adjusted basis would generally be $200,000.

If the property eventually sells for $1 million, the difference between the selling price and your adjusted basis creates a potential capital gain of $800,000, before considering selling costs and any applicable exclusions.

That gain could become taxable.

However, federal tax law provides an important benefit when someone inherits appreciated property.

It's called a step-up in basis.

What Happens to Your Property's Tax Basis When You Die?

Under federal tax rules, many inherited assets receive a basis adjustment to their fair market value at the owner's death.

This can dramatically reduce the capital gains taxes beneficiaries might otherwise owe.

Consider an individual who purchases an investment for $200,000.

When that person dies, the investment is worth $1 million.

If the asset qualifies for a full basis adjustment, the beneficiary's new basis generally becomes $1 million.

If the beneficiary immediately sells it for that amount, there may be little or no taxable capital gain.

But here's where things become more complicated for married couples.

The Problem With Jointly Owned Property in Ohio

Ohio is a separate-property state, sometimes called a common-law property state.

For many jointly owned assets, when one spouse dies, only the deceased spouse's portion receives a basis adjustment.

Let's use the same property example.

A married couple purchases property for $200,000. At the first spouse's death, it's worth $1 million.

Assuming equal ownership and a standard half-basis adjustment:

  • The deceased spouse's half receives a new basis of $500,000.

  • The surviving spouse's half retains its original $100,000 basis.

  • The property's combined adjusted basis becomes $600,000.

  • If the survivor sells it for $1 million, the potential taxable gain is $400,000.

Depending on the applicable tax rate, exclusions, and other circumstances, that remaining gain could create a substantial tax obligation.

And this is exactly the problem a Florida Community Property Trust may help address.

What Makes Community Property Different?

In traditional community property states, qualifying community property generally receives a basis adjustment on both spouses' shares when the first spouse dies.

That means the entire asset, rather than only half, may receive a new tax basis.

For a property worth $1 million, this could mean the surviving spouse receives a basis of $1 million instead of $600,000.

For families with highly appreciated real estate, investments, or business interests, the difference could be considerable.

Traditionally, this favorable treatment has been associated with states such as California, Texas, Arizona, and Wisconsin.

But several other states have adopted laws allowing married couples to elect community property treatment through specialized trusts.

Florida is one of them.

What Is a Florida Community Property Trust?

A Florida Community Property Trust is a legal arrangement that allows qualifying married couples to designate certain assets as community property under Florida law.

One of its most interesting features is that you don't necessarily have to live in Florida to establish one.

An Ohio couple may potentially create a trust governed by Florida law while continuing to reside in Ohio.

The trust can hold eligible assets such as:

  • Residential and investment real estate

  • Farmland and other appreciated land

  • Stocks and taxable investment accounts

  • Certain closely held business interests

  • Other qualifying capital assets

Traditional IRAs and 401(k) accounts generally do not receive the same capital gains basis adjustment, so they aren't the focus of this strategy.

Florida's statute also generally allows these trusts to be revocable, which can provide flexibility similar to a conventional revocable living trust.

However, the trust must satisfy specific legal requirements.

For example, Florida law requires a qualifying Florida trustee, which may be an eligible individual or financial institution.

Simply creating a document titled "Community Property Trust" isn't enough to establish the intended treatment.

Proper drafting, administration, asset transfers, and coordination with existing estate planning documents are essential.

Why This Strategy Could Be Especially Valuable for Ohio Farmers

One of the most compelling applications involves appreciated farmland.

Throughout Ohio, some families own agricultural property purchased decades ago at prices far below current market values.

Consider a hypothetical farm purchased for $1,000 per acre.

If that land is now worth $25,000 per acre, the appreciation is enormous.

Now imagine the farm is jointly owned by a married couple.

Under the standard half-basis adjustment illustrated earlier, the surviving spouse could potentially have approximately $6 million in unrealized appreciation remaining after the first spouse's death.

If the survivor later sells the farm, that gain could create a significant federal capital gains tax liability.

If the farmland qualifies for full community property basis treatment, the outcome could be dramatically different.

The surviving spouse might receive a basis adjustment on the entire property, potentially reducing the capital gains recognized on a subsequent sale.

This can create valuable flexibility.

Perhaps the surviving spouse wants to sell part of the farm to a grandchild.

Maybe the family wants to transfer ownership to a neighboring farmer.

Or perhaps the property no longer fits the family's long-term financial needs.

A properly structured plan could provide more choices without allowing potential capital gains taxes to dictate every decision.

Important: Federal tax recognition of elective community property trusts, particularly for nonresident couples, involves legal uncertainty. The projected full-basis benefit is not guaranteed.

Appreciated Stocks Create Another Planning Opportunity

Farmland isn't the only asset that can create substantial unrealized gains.

Consider an Ohio couple who accumulated company stock throughout their working careers.

Perhaps they purchased shares regularly, reinvested dividends, and held the investment for decades.

Over time, their original investment may have grown into a significant portion of their wealth.

This creates two separate concerns.

First, selling appreciated shares could trigger capital gains taxes.

Second, maintaining too much wealth in one company can expose the couple to unnecessary concentration risk.

Attorney Hersch described clients with substantial holdings in Procter & Gamble stock.

Their financial advisors encouraged diversification, but the clients were reluctant to sell because they wanted to avoid the capital gains tax.

A community property trust could potentially change the surviving spouse's options.

If the shares qualify for a full basis adjustment at the first spouse's death, the survivor might be able to sell and diversify with substantially less capital gains tax.

That flexibility can be important when coordinating investment decisions with a broader estate plan.

Of course, waiting for a future basis adjustment isn't always the best investment decision.

Market risk, liquidity needs, and the possibility of changes in tax law must also be considered.

Is a Florida Community Property Trust Right for Every Married Couple?

Not necessarily.

Although the potential tax benefits can be attractive, the strategy involves meaningful trade-offs.

1. Existing Marital Agreements May Be Affected

When assets become community property, the spouses' ownership rights can change.

This matters especially for couples with prenuptial agreements, separate-property arrangements, or different intended beneficiaries.

Transferring property into a community property trust could conflict with those plans.

2. Creditor Rights Require Careful Review

Florida's community property trust statute contains provisions affecting creditor claims.

Those provisions may operate differently from the rules governing property in traditional community property states.

Couples should understand how transferring assets could affect their exposure to creditors and the enforceability of existing obligations.

3. The IRS Could Challenge the Intended Treatment

One of the most important uncertainties involves whether the IRS will recognize the desired full basis adjustment in every circumstance.

Although elective community property trust laws have existed for many years, the federal treatment of certain arrangements has not been conclusively settled for all situations.

A favorable state-law classification does not automatically eliminate every federal tax question.

4. Assets Can Lose Value

A basis adjustment isn't always upward.

If an asset declines in value before the owner's death, its basis could be adjusted downward.

That can eliminate tax basis that might otherwise have been valuable.

5. Trust Administration Has Costs

Establishing and maintaining a Florida Community Property Trust can involve attorney fees, trustee expenses, asset transfers, and ongoing coordination.

The potential tax savings should justify those costs and complexities.

These considerations make individualized legal and tax advice essential.

How Does This Fit Into Your Existing Estate Plan?

For some married couples, a Florida Community Property Trust may serve as a foundational estate planning document.

For others, it may be more appropriate to establish a separate trust for specific assets.

The appropriate structure depends on your circumstances.

For example, couples who share the same beneficiaries and intend to leave their assets to each other may have different planning needs from couples who want to preserve separate inheritances.

A coordinated plan should address questions such as:

  • Which assets could benefit most from community property treatment?

  • How would the trust affect ownership rights during marriage?

  • What happens to the trust after the first spouse dies?

  • How does the arrangement interact with existing wills and trusts?

  • Could the strategy create complications involving creditors, taxes, or beneficiaries?

The goal isn't simply to establish another trust.

It's to make sure every document and ownership arrangement works together to accomplish your family's objectives.

Don't Confuse Capital Gains Planning With Estate Tax Planning

Another important distinction is the difference between capital gains taxes and federal estate taxes.

A Florida Community Property Trust primarily addresses the potential income tax consequences associated with appreciated assets.

Federal estate taxes involve a separate set of rules governing transfers of wealth at death.

For 2026, the federal estate and gift tax basic exclusion amount is $15 million per person under current law.

This is an important update from the podcast's discussion, which reflected earlier expectations that the exemption would decrease in 2026.

The law changed after that discussion was recorded.

For families with substantial estates, additional strategies involving lifetime gifts, irrevocable trusts, and generation-skipping transfer tax planning may also be relevant.

But these techniques serve different purposes.

An estate plan designed to reduce estate taxes isn't automatically the best plan for preserving capital gains basis.

Likewise, a strategy focused on basis adjustments may not provide the asset protection or inheritance controls your family needs.

Effective estate planning considers these issues together.

The Biggest Opportunity May Be the Flexibility You Leave Behind

When people think about estate planning, they often focus on deciding who receives their property.

That's important, but it's only part of the picture.

The way you own your assets today can affect how much flexibility your surviving spouse has tomorrow.

An appreciated investment might be difficult to sell because of the tax consequences.

A family farm might represent millions of dollars in wealth but create complications when ownership changes.

A property that once served your family's needs might eventually need to be sold.

Thoughtful planning can help address these possibilities before they become urgent.

And for some married couples, a Florida Community Property Trust may offer another option worth evaluating.

The key is understanding both its potential benefits and its limitations before transferring assets or changing ownership arrangements.

Take the Next Step Toward Protecting Your Family's Wealth

If you and your spouse own highly appreciated real estate, farmland, investments, or business interests, your current ownership structure deserves a closer look.

A Florida Community Property Trust may be worth discussing with qualified estate planning and tax professionals, especially if you're concerned about the potential capital gains taxes your surviving spouse could face.

Watch the full episode of Repair the Roof to hear Attorney Ted Gudorf and Attorney Craig Hersch explain how Florida Community Property Trusts work, why Ohio families may want to consider them, and which important risks deserve attention.

[Watch the Full Video]

Conclusion: Your Estate Plan Should Protect More Than Your Assets

Building wealth takes years of effort, careful decisions, and patience.

But preserving that wealth for your spouse and family requires more than simply naming beneficiaries or signing a trust.

It requires understanding how ownership, tax rules, and estate planning strategies interact.

A Florida Community Property Trust presents an intriguing opportunity for certain Ohio married couples who hold substantial appreciated assets.

While the strategy isn't appropriate for everyone and its intended federal tax treatment isn't guaranteed, it highlights an important principle:

The decisions you make about your property today can significantly affect the options available to your family tomorrow.

As President Kennedy famously observed, the time to repair the roof is when the sun is shining.

The same principle applies to estate planning.

Planning before circumstances change gives you more time to evaluate your choices and protect what matters most.

Transcript: Prefer to Read — Click to Open

Florida Community Property Trust For Ohio Resident and The Upcoming Estate Tax Cliff With Attorney Craig Hersch

Ted Gudorf (00:01.09)

Today’s topic is Florida Community Property Trust and how they can help folks who live in Ohio. Today’s guest is attorney Craig Hirsch from the Shepherd Law Firm in Fort Myers, Florida. Welcome, Craig.

Craig Hersch (00:16.144)

Thanks, Ted. Thanks for having me.

Ted Gudorf (00:17.878)

Craig, my understanding is you’re certified specialist in estate planning. How long you been doing this?

Craig Hersch (00:24.368)

I’m in my 35th year of practice. So yeah, 35 years. And I’ve been a board certified in Florida since I was eligible, which is five years in.

Ted Gudorf (00:36.246)

Great. Well, look, the Community Property Trust statute is new in Florida, is my understanding. Why don’t you tell us a little bit about how the statute came to be adopted when it took

Craig Hersch (00:48.068)

Yeah, the statute’s about two years old, two and a half years old now. The idea behind it is to give residents or not even residents, can be, as we’ll talk a little bit later, you can be an Ohio resident and get the Florida benefit as well. But it’s for people who are of common law states to get community property tax treatment. And that’s largely associated with what’s colloquially known as the step up in tax cost basis.

So we’ll talk about that today a little bit.

Ted Gudorf (01:19.414)

So the type of asset that this applies to, does this apply to everything that I own, or is it only certain assets?

Craig Hersch (01:28.28)

Yeah, it applies to most everything you own. Real estate, it could apply to a business, a closely held business interest. It can apply to investments. Although assets inside of qualified retirement accounts, such as an IRA account or a 401k account, those do not get any step up in basis treatment. But most everything else that you own would.

Ted Gudorf (01:52.076)

So we’re really talking about what I call capital assets.

And so a capital asset under the tax law has something called basis. What is basis?

Craig Hersch (02:05.648)

Yeah, basis is basically what you paid for it plus any additions. For example, if I bought a residence and I paid $200 ,000 for it, but then I did an add on, I added a room for $50 ,000. My new basis is $250 ,000. And that’s what I paid for it plus what I added to it. And that’s a real simple explanation of what basis is.

Ted Gudorf (02:29.218)

So what happens if you have that, say, an apartment building that you paid $250 ,000 for and it appreciates in value and then you want to sell it under the tax law, what happens?

Craig Hersch (02:33.943)

we froze.

Craig Hersch (02:49.264)

So if I paid $250 ,000 for an apartment building, we were getting cut off there a little bit. let’s make sure that I understood. Why don’t you say the question again and then I’ll answer it.

Ted Gudorf (03:01.964)

So why don’t we talk a little bit about what is basis?

Craig Hersch (04:02.884)

Okay, basis Ted is basically what you paid for a capital asset. For example, your residence. If you bought your residence for 150 ,000 or two, let’s call it $150 ,000. And then let’s say you later added a room and it costs you $50 ,000, your basis and the properties, what you paid for those things, which would then equal $200 ,000.

Ted Gudorf (03:58.668)

So it’s what we paid for the capital asset plus any improvements. And that particularly applies to things like real estate or stock or our business assets, correct?

Craig Hersch (04:02.884)

That’s right.

Craig Hersch (04:11.536)

Right. Let’s take investments, for example. If I bought an investment, I put $10 ,000 into a stock holding. And if I was reinvesting the dividends, if I had a drip plan, a dividend reinvestment plan, my new basis would be what I paid for that stock plus the dividends that I reinvested.

Ted Gudorf (04:33.142)

Very good. Why do we care about that? Why do we care about basis? If we never sell the asset, does it ever really matter?

Craig Hersch (04:42.072)

Yeah, that’s called an unrealized gain and we don’t recognize a capital gain. We don’t pay capital gains taxes on an asset until we’ve sold it. And that’s when we realize the gain, which is generally speaking, the difference between the sales price and our basis.

Ted Gudorf (04:58.956)

So once again, if we never sell the asset, then we don’t have to pay any tax on that gain. So we’re really talking about situations where somebody owns a capital asset, and they’re going to sell it, let’s say initially, during their lifetime. What you’re saying is that we’re going to pay a capital gains tax, right?

Craig Hersch (05:05.338)

That’s right.

Craig Hersch (05:23.492)

Yeah, that’s right.

Ted Gudorf (05:24.684)

So under the federal tax law, tell me a little bit about the difference between a capital gains tax and an ordinary income tax.

Craig Hersch (05:35.984)

Yeah, that’s a good question. As you’re aware, ordinary income is taxed at the highest marginal federal rate today is 37 % when we’re filming this podcast episode, whereas the highest capital gains rate is 20%. Although if you have additional income, you might be paying a Medicare surtax, which is 3 .8%. So our maximum capital gains tax is as high as 23 .8 % as opposed to 37 % on ordinary income.

Ted Gudorf (06:08.244)

So not only do we get a little bit of a break on the sale of a capital asset compared to say W -2 wage income, we also have some other tax benefits with capital assets. Let’s talk about what happens when we pass away and we own a highly appreciated capital asset. What does the tax law say about that?

Craig Hersch (06:35.088)

Well, if with a highly appreciated asset, let’s say that I own an asset that’s worth a million dollars today, but I only paid $200 ,000 for it and I die holding that asset. Well, now my heirs, my beneficiaries get that asset at its new basis, at the adjusted basis at the time of my death, a million dollars. So if they then sold that asset for a million dollars, they would recognize no capital gains tax.

And contrast that where if I sold it the day before my death, I would have had an $800 ,000 capital gain to pay taxes on.

Ted Gudorf (07:14.604)

So one strategy with respect to folks who own a capital asset, whether it be stock or real estate, if they really are not interested in paying the capital gains tax, one strategy is simply hold the asset until you pass away and then have your heirs sell it soon thereafter. And that pretty well wipes out any capital gains tax.

Craig Hersch (07:42.128)

That’s right, but consider if I hold that asset jointly with my spouse. Okay, if I live in a common law state, there are 41 common law states. Ohio is one of them, Florida is another. Let’s go back to my same example. I own it jointly with my wife, the $200 ,000 that we paid $200 ,000 for that property. I die and it’s worth a million. Well, in that case, we only get a step up in basis on my half in a common law state.

So my original basis on my half was 100 ,000. My half of the adjusted value at the time of my death is 500 ,000. So my half jumps up to 500 ,000. My wife’s half still stays at 100. So what that means is if she sells it the day after my death, she still has a $400 ,000 capital gain.

Ted Gudorf (08:34.272)

That is a big deal.

Craig Hersch (08:36.91)

Yeah, it really is because so many married couples own their investments, they own their properties jointly. Now contrast this with a common, with a community property state. There are nine community property states. They stretch from Louisiana, West to California and up to Washington with the exceptions being Oregon is not a community property state, whereas Idaho is and Wisconsin is also.

a community property state out there in the Midwest. So in any event, if I live in a community property state, same set of facts, wife and I bought the residence for 200 ,000, it’s now worth a million, I die, only I die. She gets a step up all the way up to a million in a community property state. So she sells it the next day after my death, no capital gain at all, as opposed to residents of common law states, Ohio being among them,

she would still have a $400 ,000 gain on which to pay tax.

Ted Gudorf (09:41.122)

You know, Craig, some might say the unequal treatment from a community property state to a separate property state doesn’t make sense when we’re dealing with federal law. Because shouldn’t federal law be the same for all 50 states? How is it possible that it can be different?

Craig Hersch (10:03.14)

You know, that’s a great question. And you would think that it is a federal law, so we would all pay the same tax, right? But here’s the thing, a lot of federal tax law is state dependent, how the state treats the asset. So, and this is where these community property opt -in trusts come into play. But in any event, the IRS says, well, if the state treats it this way, we’ll treat it that way as well. And that’s where, you you have a federal government.

of 50 states and each state has their own laws. So in some respects, state law can affect the federal tax law.

Ted Gudorf (10:40.418)

So here, both your state, Florida, and my state, Ohio, are separate property states. We’re not one of the community property states, correct? So tell me if you’re in Florida and you’re a separate property state, now all of a sudden we’re introducing a community property option.

Craig Hersch (10:51.716)

That’s right. That’s right.

Ted Gudorf (11:06.964)

into Florida law. How did how does that work?

Craig Hersch (11:10.32)

Yeah, well, actually, Florida is the fifth state to enact a law like this. Alaska was the first about 26 years ago, and then South Dakota followed a few years after that, then Tennessee, Kentucky, and now Florida. And what these five states have decided is they want to enable a resident of a common law state, like Ohio, like Florida, to get the same tax benefits as a resident of a community property state.

They created this law where you can create a community property trust and then put those assets in that trust and you get community property treatment under state law. And because you get community property treatment under state law, you end up with the community property benefit under the federal tax law.

Ted Gudorf (12:04.424)

And that community property benefit includes either a step up or I suppose we should also mention potentially a step down in the value.

Craig Hersch (12:16.144)

Yeah, a lot of people think everything’s a step up as you point out, but it’s really what the tax code says in the code section is 1014. And what it says is an adjustment to fair market value at the time of death. So in most cases, that’s a step up, meaning that it is adjusted upwards because it is appreciated in value. Excuse me, if the asset is depreciated in value, it could be a step down.

Ted Gudorf (12:44.716)

So let’s talk a little bit about this trust concept. Is this a revocable trust? Is it an irrevocable trust? What does this trust look like? And who can create it? Who can be the trust makers and who can be the trustees of it? What does it look like?

Craig Hersch (13:01.23)

Yeah, that’s another great question. Now in some of the states, and these states are the ones that have domestic asset protection statutes like Ohio’s. I think it’s Alaska, South Dakota, and Tennessee, their trusts are by default irrevocable. Florida’s is by default revocable.

So unless you make it irrevocable to revocable trust, very similar to any joint trust that you might create between a husband and a wife or a husband and a husband, we have same -sex couples as well. But so long as it’s a married couple and they create the trust and they opt into this community property treatment. Now, one of the things about opting in a community property treatment,

is the fact that you have, let’s say I have a nuptial agreement with my spouse, and let’s say that it says on divorce, I get 70 % and she gets 30%, or we have some kind of financial arrangement that’s different than what would otherwise be community property, which is 50 -50. So if I put these assets into a community property trust, all five state statutes are similar in this respect.

It’s treated as community property and any other agreement that you may have had about these assets you’ve transferred in is no longer applicable to lease those assets. And there’s creditor rights issues as well that we can get into.

Ted Gudorf (14:33.974)

So when you’re forming them in Florida, that’s an interesting option. Are you doing both revocable and irrevocable, or have you gone one way or the other?

Craig Hersch (14:45.978)

The ones that we’ve done for our clients are mostly revocable because unless we’re doing some estate tax planning, we want to make, but you know, here’s the problem. When you make them irrevocable, then you have to somehow trigger the step up another way through, let’s say an intentionally defective general power of appointment, which is a technique that you use to give the spouses the right to direct the assets.

Yeah, you know, the the irrevocable trust segment of it is usually in a domestic asset protection trust type of a scenario, which that’s a law that we do not have in Florida. We’ve tried to get it several times, but the bankers lobby and the personal injury lobby is very strong in Florida and we haven’t been able to to accomplish that. but yeah, in direct answer to your question, most of the ones we do are revoke.

Ted Gudorf (15:40.62)

So in that case, if you have a married couple, who’s the trustee?

Craig Hersch (15:45.238)

the grantors are usually the married couple themselves and the trustees can be the married couple, just like a regular revocable trust.

Ted Gudorf (15:53.672)

And do you find that it oftentimes will mirror the provisions of their standard revocable trust?

Craig Hersch (16:00.792)

Yeah, and in fact, in many cases, what we’ve done with our clients is it just replaces their old joint trust. You know, the only time again that we normally worry about a different scenario is when we have assets that the couple want to keep separate and distinct pursuant to some kind of a nuptial agreement.

Ted Gudorf (16:24.032)

So are you ever in a situation where you’re creating a separate opt -in trust for a husband and a wife? Yeah.

Craig Hersch (16:29.996)

yeah. Yeah, but it’s less common. Most of our clients, their foundational document is the Opt -in Trust, the community property Opt -in Trust. And it’s the foundational document because, you know, most of our clients have the same beneficiaries. You they’ve been married a long time. They don’t have an actual agreement. So for that couple of community property trust is ideal.

Ted Gudorf (16:56.684)

So give me some examples of the types of assets that individuals who have come to you have placed in this community property trust.

Craig Hersch (17:08.673)

Residences both inside and outside of Florida. Their investments that are not in IRAs.

Ted Gudorf (17:14.24)

Now, before you go on, I thought we had an exemption that applied to our residences that wouldn’t be needed for this kind of scenario.

Craig Hersch (17:25.744)

Yeah, which what you’re talking about there is a section 125 exemption, which is the, know, when I sell my primary residence, that’s been my primary residence for two of the last five years. Then I have an exemption of 125 ,000 for an individual or 200 or I’m sorry, it’s 250 ,000 for an individual. $500 ,000 for a married couple. But let’s say that I have a home that has appreciated beyond that 500 ,000, right?

If that’s the case, the Community Property Trust helps out in the sense that we eliminate all of the capital gain, not just $500 ,000 of it.

Ted Gudorf (18:04.29)

So we’re really talking about households where they own a residence that simply is over 500 ,000, which is pretty common these days. Yeah, got it.

Craig Hersch (18:13.808)

Well, over 500 ,000 in appreciation. Yeah, yeah. And you know that anybody who’s held their home for a long time, you know, might be bumping up against that or over that depending upon, you know, where they are and so forth. it’s a residences both inside and outside of Florida. You could have a residence anywhere and put in a community property trust in their investment accounts. And again, they don’t have to be in Florida. It can be anywhere.

the investment accounts. Depreciated property is another great example. So if I own a strip center and then I can get community property trust treatment on that, now it gets a little bit more complicated if it’s inside a partnership, which a lot of those depreciated properties are in, commercial properties are in. But almost any kind of…

of property is a good idea to put into an investment into a community property trust.

Ted Gudorf (19:16.002)

Fascinating. Now let’s talk a little bit about its application in particular to Ohio residents. How is it that, let’s say I happen to represent a lot of farmers and our farm values in Ohio have just skyrocketed. You know I have clients of mine who paid a thousand dollars an acre and today the land is selling in excess of 25 ,000 an acre and they own 500 acres.

Craig Hersch (19:44.73)

Yeah.

Ted Gudorf (19:45.078)

But typically in our farm scenario, our farm couples, they own everything jointly. And I will say this, oftentimes the husband passes away first and the wife is there and she wants to sell the property. I mean, and sometimes she’s selling it maybe to a grandchild or selling it to a neighbor or something like that.

an Ohio resident maybe who owns a farm, how would this work? How and why does it work for an Ohio resident to be able to create a Florida trust? Is it really possible for somebody from Ohio to create a Florida trust?

Craig Hersch (20:31.504)

In theory it is. Now, Alaska’s had these statutes for 25, 26 years. And most of the people establishing Alaska Community Property Trust were not Alaska residents. They were residents of other states because of what Alaska did in trying to do this and South Dakota did, and now Florida. The idea is to try to attract investments to the state. Now, what Alaska did and many of other states do is they say you need

Ted Gudorf (20:43.394)

Sure.

Craig Hersch (21:01.088)

an Alaska bank or trust company to serve as a trustee. And that’s how they invite the individuals who want to use Alaska law to their benefit. And that’s what benefits Alaska. Now in Florida, for example, you can name a resident, you need a Florida resident or a Florida trust company or bank or national bank as a trustee.

So that’s the one catch that an Ohio resident would need is they would need somebody in Florida to serve as a trustee. But so long as they had that, then they would qualify under the Florida Community Property Trust statute. They could put their Ohio farmland in it and then achieve community property status.

Ted Gudorf (21:49.866)

And that seems pretty straightforward, pretty easy to do. Any controversy about that at all?

Craig Hersch (21:58.224)

Well, know, commentators have suggested that the IRS may challenge it, but remember that Alaska statute is now 26 years old and I’m not familiar with any challenges to it from the federal IRS. One of the sticking points that some of the commentators suggest the IRS might use if they were to try to use it is the creditor issue. In normal community property states,

husband and wife are liable for each other’s debt. a creditor, like if I’m a doctor and I own community property with my wife, okay, and there’s a, I have a liability to a judgment creditor, they can attach to our community property assets. Now, Florida statute says, for example, that the only assets that are subject to that individual’s creditors

are that individual share of the community property. So, you know, there are some differences legally between a community property state law and how community property normally works and these community property statute laws. And there is no uniform community property law out there. So these states are drafting their own statutes and they’re very different from one another.

Kentucky and Tennessee’s and South Dakota’s really are quite simple. They don’t really go into much. Florida’s is much more in depth. Florida’s a more recent one. What Florida does, interestingly with creditors, this is interesting too, is an independent trustee, not one of the grantors who are trustees. So husband and wife, even if they’re serving as trustee, they can’t do this that I’m about to talk about. But what an independent trustee can do.

is allocate certain assets as satisfying the community property share. Now in Florida, there’s a Florida homestead exemption that’s very, very difficult. Creditors generally cannot get to your Florida homestead. So let’s say if that’s your primary residence, that’s your Florida homestead, it’s your primary residence. Let’s say that you have a…

Craig Hersch (24:21.7)

a million dollars of residents and a million dollars of investments. Well, the investments a judgment creditor could easily get to, But what the independent trustee could do is say, well, the husband share in this case, I’m saying the husband is liable, is the homestead and wife’s share are all the investments. So they can play some games under the Florida law with creditor protection. And even though Ohio residents don’t have a

Florida homestead, because by definition, they’re Ohio residents, they could still play games. For example, if they have assets that are in an LLC that are harder for a creditor can get to under the Florida statute, you could allocate that interest to the debtor spouse. So there’s some creditor issues, but again, the IRS has not brought those up. And an Ohio resident is free to use the Florida statute if he or she wants to.

Ted Gudorf (25:20.492)

Fascinating. when we kind of wrap this up, for those clients who have highly appreciated assets, who own them, husband and wife, probably a longstanding marriage.

who want to take advantage and give their spouse the option of being able to sell that appreciated asset after one of them dies and not pay any capital gains tax, this seems like kind of an ideal solution for those couples.

Craig Hersch (25:54.776)

Yeah, to me, it’s a no brainer because let’s assume that the IRS actually challenges the community property status for some reason. Where are we? Well, the couple’s put back in the same position that they would have been in. They’re still going to get a half step up in tax cost basis. So the only thing that really out is the legal fees and costs associated with the establishment of the community property trust. But again,

I haven’t seen anything where the IRS is challenging these. That’s not to say that someone’s going to be the first at some point.

Ted Gudorf (26:34.39)

Well, and I think on top of that, you and I both understand that in the community property states, the step up at the first death is automatic and the IRS has never challenged that.

Craig Hersch (26:47.47)

Yeah. So what I’m talking about is the full step up. They have to challenge that. But yeah, my view is it’s worth a shot because even if it fails, you’re still in the same position you would have been otherwise. And if it works out, you’ve eliminated a substantial amount of capital gains, which then frees. I have some clients, I’m sure you do also, Ted.

Ted Gudorf (26:50.452)

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Craig Hersch (27:15.856)

I’ll give you an example, right there in Ohio, Procter & Gamble. So I had some clients who owned a lot of Procter & Gamble stock because they worked at Procter & Gamble. And a lot of it was outside of a qualified retirement account. was just investments that they owned. And all their financial advisors were urging them to sell some of it because they were overweighted in one stock and they wouldn’t do it not only because they thought it was a good investment, but because…

they were afraid of paying the capital gains tax. They didn’t wanna pay the capital gains tax. Well, if you put all that Procter & Gamble stock into a community property opt -in trust, and then one spouse dies, the surviving spouse suddenly has the option of diversifying if he or she wants to, whereas before they would have paid a lot of capital gains tax to accomplish that.

Ted Gudorf (28:05.122)

Great. Let’s shift gears a little bit. We’ve got some changing landscape that may be happening over the course of the next couple of years with respect to the federal estate tax. When I started to practice in 1986, the federal exemption amount, that is the amount that each one of us could pass tax free to our children, was somewhere around $600 ,000.

What’s the exemption amount today and what changes are we looking at coming down the road

Craig Hersch (28:41.968)

Yeah, the exemption amount today is what’s over $13 million, as I recall. And what happens is the current law sunsets at the end of 2025, which…

Ted Gudorf (28:56.214)

When you say sunsets, what does that mean?

Craig Hersch (28:59.184)

What that means is it was an act passed during the Trump administration in 2017 because it was passed through budget reconciliation as opposed to what it would normally need is 60 Senate votes to pass. It didn’t have the 60 Senate votes to pass.

Ted Gudorf (29:09.506)

2017, 2018, somewhere in there, yeah.

Craig Hersch (29:26.096)

The only way they could do it is through budget reconciliation, which is at a maximum 10 years. And you’re thinking, well, why didn’t it go to 2027 when the law was passed in 2017? I think it was the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act is the name of the statute. But in any event, the reason it only went eight years is because under a budget reconciliation can only increase the deficit by so much. So.

It had to be stopped in eight years. So what happens is the law that has these huge exemptions now for us, you more than $26 million between a married couple, is now sunsets at the end of 2025, which means it goes back to the old law, which is the law that they passed during the Obama administration, which was basically $5 million exemption per person and then adjusted to inflation. The pundits believe based on the inflation numbers that

that it will fall somewhere between six and $7 million to each person. So in other words, between a married couple or even for an individual, the exemption amount will roughly half. It’ll be cut in half between on January 1st of 2026.

Ted Gudorf (30:44.642)

So if I’m a single person and I have an estate worth more than $7 million and I am going to, let’s assume I pass away after January 1, 2026, you’re saying we’re going to pay a federal estate tax. Does the rate change as well?

Craig Hersch (31:04.336)

Well, the rate would go back to the Obama rates, which is 40 % is the top rate, as I recall.

Ted Gudorf (31:15.81)

So we’re going to pay a federal estate tax of some amount over the excess, over the $7 million exemption amount for a single person.

Craig Hersch (31:27.664)

That’s right. Now, what most wealthy clients should consider between now and the end of next year is to use up that exemption, the 13 plus million dollar exemption, before it expires. Because that exemption is not just an estate tax credit exemption. It’s a gift and a state tax exemption, meaning that my exemption covers gifts that I make during my lifetime.

as well as the transfers that I make at death and it’s one exemption. So if I use it all up during my lifetime, then there’s no more left at my passing. Now these are gifts above what we call the annual exclusion amount, which today’s 18 ,000. I can give $18 ,000 to anyone I want and it’s not counted towards my gift tax exemption. But once I make gifts above that, then it’s counted.

Ted Gudorf (32:22.21)

So the lifetime exemption amount is over $13 million today. It’s going back to roughly $7 million on January 1, 2026. Do I understand that right? So the opportunity each of us has is if we have an estate that’s valued above that amount between now and the time the law changes, we have the ability to give away during our lifetime

Craig Hersch (32:35.512)

Yes, yes.

Ted Gudorf (32:51.778)

that $13 million and you’re saying if we do that, even though the law is going to change in 2026, we’re still going to be okay. They’re going to recognize that gift that we’re making perhaps to a trust for our spouse or for our kids.

Craig Hersch (33:05.125)

Yeah.

Craig Hersch (33:10.0)

That’s right. I just verified, I looked it up. It’s $13 .61 million in 2024. Last year it was 12 .92. So it’s going up significantly. Probably will go up again next year. But yeah, you’re right. Once you’ve made that gift, it’s outside of your estate. Now there are certain types of gifts that can be clawed back if they’re made within three years of death. Insurance is a common example of that. If I have a life insurance policy and I…

put it into an irrevocable trust. And that’s another point. When we’re making these gifts, they should be either outright or in a trust, an irrevocable trust. If the grantor has the power to have the income off the gift, generally speaking, there’s some exceptions to all this, has the power to direct it, has the power to receive the income off the gift, then it’s not really a completed gift. Excuse me.

It’s not really complete a gift for a gift and estate tax purposes. So you would do this. And I suggest all my clients, let’s use an irrevocable trust. And the other idea is to use up not only your gift and estate tax exemption, but there’s something called the generation skipping transfer tax exemption. Now this doesn’t mean that you’re skipping your children. What it means is you’re skipping your children for gift and estate tax purposes. In other words, if I created,

a trust for my daughter, and the trust is designed to go on for her children’s lifetimes after her. The gift is, and we apply my generation skipping transfer tax exemption to it. Then at her death, no matter what that gift has ballooned to, you know, might’ve doubled in value over the course of her lifetime. It’s not included in her estate for estate tax purposes.

So the generation skipping transfer tax exemption is equally as important to your family as is the gift in estate tax exemption.

Ted Gudorf (35:14.594)

So that’s fascinating. So it sounds like we have lot of planning opportunities over the next couple years here to try to do some estate tax planning for those clients who have a substantial wealth above and beyond the seven million if you’re single or 14 million if you’re a married couple.

Craig Hersch (35:34.788)

Yes, certainly.

Ted Gudorf (35:36.748)

Well, Craig, it’s been great having you with me today. I really appreciate your insight, your expertise. It’s really insightful. I learned a lot. Thanks for being with us.

Back to All Episodes